Real Estate and All That Jazz: 5 Good Reasons Landlords Won't Rent To Dogs---And I Love Dogs!

5 Good Reasons Landlords Won't Rent To Dogs---And I Love Dogs!

WOOF WOOF
I don't hate dogs--quite the contrary. When my daughter was small, we had a loveable Golden Retriever named Bernie. My daughter and he were the best of friends. He would protect her, and lick all of the day's food off her face before I had a chance to get the facecloth. His loyalty and gratitude to us for being his "people" was never ending. He got cancer at 12 years old and had to be put down. Needless to say it was a devastating event for the entire family. And to this day, every time I see a Golden Retriever puppy I am tempted..but then reality sets in and I realize it just wouldn't fit into my lifestyle--and I even own my own home!

One of the problems I encounter as a property owner  in San Diego CA is that tenants love dogs too. I don't allow dogs in any of my properties and I have had to turn away some good tenants. They asked me why I hate animals so much!

Here is a list of the 5 main reasons property owners in San Diego CA do not allow dogs.

 

Noise
Dogs bark. Your dog doesn't bark at all when you are at work all day and has nothing to do but sit in an empty house, lonely and bored? How would you know? Do you have videotape running? Dogs bark, plain and simple. They are supposed to bark, that is what dogs do. You may not mind it, but I bet your neighbor who works nights and is sleeping during the day does.

Liability
Insurance companies deny dog bite claims to owners who own dogs of certain breeds: Pit Bull, Rottweiller and German Shepard to name a few. If your dog is a mutt, he/she may have part of this breed and depending on the amount (they can do a test), your claim can be denied. Sounds crazy? Some insurance companies have Labrador Retrievers as an unwanted breed.  This borders on the ridiculous, as we all know Labradors have to be the kindest dogs on the planet earth. But you may ask what can a 3 pound Chihuahua do? Well they can deliver a nasty bite to an infant. One of my friends was bit on the finger by one and it was a pretty deep bite. Think lawsuit.

Denied Access
If a tenant does not want you in their house, a loose dog will carry out their wishes. Would you as an agent enter a house with a Pit Bull running around? A few years ago, I had a client who desperately needed me to sell his rental house, but the tenant and he had an altercation.  She actually said it was ok to come in, but her 60 pound "friendly"  Pit Bull was loose inside and she had no plans to tether it.. (Oh and did I mention the tenant in the back was breeding rabbits? But I digress)

Destruction of Property and Landscaping
Did you ever see a large dog dig holes? Or a small terrier "tunnel"? You know what I mean when I say destruction. And what about dog excrement that a lazy owner is just too busy to pick up daily? I had a tenant that figured if a dog poops on the snow, then it will just disappear miraculously. Well folks, I can tell you this isn't the case. In the Spring, after the snow thawed on the 1/2 acre of grass, guess what I found perfectly preserved in small bundles (6 months X 30...get my drift)? It was not a very happy day for me.

Humane Reasons
I don't know about you, but anyone with a large dog who has no moral problem with it sitting in a small apartment all day gets my vote for "Loser". It's cruel and I would feel ethically unable to allow this in my property.Tethering a dog all day in a yard is not an alternative since this leads to boredom and barking.

 

The time to adopt a dog is when you are settled in a home that you own----That's easy!! Become a property owner in San Diego CA.

 

Join My Facebook Group- San Diego Real Estate Forum

Deborah A. Stone, Realtor  Integrity-Solutions-Results-

Hogue and Belong Realty-Bankers Hill

San Diego, CA

"Representing clients with the experience of an investor"

11 commentsDEBORAH STONE • June 04 2010 03:21PM

Comments

Deborah,

Very good list and it sure explains why most home owners everywhere (including those in MT) don't want to rent their property to anyone with dogs. 

I love dogs too.  I have 3 dogs and that is one of the advantages of owning versus renting when it comes to your residence.  The dogs love the bigger outdoor space here in Montana.  :)

Any smart tenant should wait till they get their own place before getting any pets otherwise they are going to have a very difficult time finding a place or have to come up with more money up front with a pet deposit in addition to the security deposit.

Posted by Gerry Khatchikian, ASA, TRC, SFR Greetings from Red Lodge, Montana! 3 months ago

Gerry-

Renting to tenants with dogs has always been a "lose-lose" situation. Some of my clients allow dogs, but I discourage it for most. Of all the problems I have had with being a Landlord and Property Manager, 95% of them were due to dogs.

I have had some issues with cats (which I do allow) but the destruction-noise-liability reasons are not problems with cats. I have been scratched deeply by a cat showing a home, but I made the mistake of approaching her, so it was my fault.

All I can say is, time to buy a house and adopt your dog of choice!

Posted by DEBORAH STONE (Hogue and Belong Bankers Hill- San Diego, CA) 3 months ago

I hear you on this one. You are preaching to the choir. One of the other tenants in our office building brings dogs to work. Nobody likes that--except for him, I suppose.

Posted by Melissa Zavala RealtorĀ® North San Diego County Homes (Broadpoint Properties) 3 months ago

Unless my property owner will return to the property * I allow pets....2 small or 1 large that COMES with the family * in 20 years, I have not had a problem!!!

Posted by Wallace S. Gibson CPM * GRI (Gibson Management Group, Ltd.) 3 months ago

I think those are some pretty good reasons, and I love dogs, too! Number 5 is particularly frustrating to me when I see that.

Posted by Russel Ray, San Diego Business & Marketing Consultant & Photographer (Russel Ray) 2 months ago

Russell

Yes I think that's the worst----a pet home all day alone. Sad and I won't allow it.

Posted by DEBORAH STONE (Hogue and Belong Bankers Hill- San Diego, CA) 2 months ago

I do not prefer to allow dogs in my personal rentals but I have realized someone who is looking would rather forego the house than part with their family pet.  I am now willing to accept pets upon approval.  (I moved into a house behind 2 dogs and I was NOT a happy camper as I cleaned hair from everything....uggh!!)

Posted by Latonia Parks (Paradigm Real Estate, Fayetteville NC, Home of Ft. Bragg, NC) 2 months ago

Latonia

Thanks for stopping by my Blog. I truly believe one needs to have a permanent home before they adopt a dog. I guess if the rental market were tight here in San Diego, I may reconsider a small dog, but that is not the case. I will go with the canine-less tenant!

Posted by DEBORAH STONE (Hogue and Belong Bankers Hill- San Diego, CA) 2 months ago

Deborah,

I agree, I am a dog owner myself and although they come with many blessings and become family, there are many problems that can arise from them as well.

Posted by Beyonca Clark (Century21 New Millennium) 2 months ago

Deborah as I rule, I don't allow pets in any of my personal properties and I also discourage my owners from allowing this also.  We don't know how well a pet owner has cared for and trained their animal and in addition to destruction of property, gaining access is my second biggest concern.

Posted by Charita Cadenhead, Bham Broker/Property Manager (Bham WIiRE Realty, LLC (Sales & Property Management)) about 1 month ago

Beyonca-

Thanks for your comment on my Blog and realizing that they can cause problems.

Charita-

Same here---no dogs in my own properties and I advise my clients the same. Gaining access can be a problem even with a tiny dog.....so just because a pet is small does not mean it is not a danger. Dogs are bred to protect and will attack if threatened, unlike cats which will just go hide under the bed and hiss. (hopefully)

Posted by DEBORAH STONE (Hogue and Belong Bankers Hill- San Diego, CA) about 1 month ago

Participate



(optional)
What does the graphic say?